Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

  • Don't miss out on all the fun! Register on our forums to post and have added features! Membership levels include a FREE membership tier.

Socialism 101

Originally Posted by Grizzly Adams
Wow very interesting thread. As a political history major many moons ago in university I think this debate has gone on for years and still most people miss the jist of it. Name me one case where socialism has worked for any population, anywhere, anytime. Never has a socialist govt worked in a democratic state no matter which case you want to refer to. To remove the carrot at the end of the democratic stick is totally rubbish.
The self serving lazy people who embrace socialism are not grounded in fact and are totally ignorant of history. As humans we tend to want all the benefits of affluence and are not willing to make the sacrifices needed to accomplish this. The socialists who are attempting to run this continent are only ignorant and too lazy to better their own lot in life and expect that wealth and prosperity will magically fall from the sky.
The pioneers who laid the foundation of freedom for the citizens of this continent all made sacrifices and risked everything they had to create a wonderful world without the feudal trappings of the countries of origin they emigrated from. This continent was founded on hard work and sacrifice. The socialist movement is the most hypocritical think tank in the world. Change for no other reason than change itself is always a step backwards.
People who are willing to risk personal assets and take risks to better themselves need to have a reward for their efforts. Socialism removes the motivation from people and does not account for some of the most basic instincts of any human. Also history tells us that the only 2 remedies for economic turmoil as we are in now is war or prudent fiscal management. No other logical method exists and none ever will. History can be a great teacher as we tend to want to learn the lessons of our forefathers the hard way again and again.
For the first time in many years we have a fiscally responsible govt in my country and check out the value of our currency is today and look in 3 more months. Parity will happen this year the way the govt is devaluing your $. BTW he is failing miserably at every financial hurdle.
Good luck with that socialism idea, try Hugo Chavez on that 1 and ask the average Venezuelan what they think of socialism. Rant over will check back for the usual lame excuses. My conservative bros. will prevail as they always do!



This is a great post Grizz and I totally agree with you.

You know, there is one socialist country that the libbys try to use as a success story but they are rich with oil and that is the only way it can work.

Norway has government health care and zero national debt but it's a lame example.

Ruffy, we ask one more time, what are you Obama lovers using as "your" example of a good working government, socialist or not?
 
Will do...
So yes, capitalism is better then socialism. Capitalism motivates people better then socialism.
My question to Grizz. If socialism removes motivation, what would you say about the motivations of societies that have no form of economic / government policy? Are they not motivated to live life?
Do humans need governments and money to motivate themselves? Is the motivation that capitalism creates only good, or does it cause harm also?

Here is what the declaration says about governments will that do?

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. That to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.

As for money it is merely a means of exchange as the world has evolved to the point it isn't praqcticle to trade chickens for wheat etc, I am sure even you can understand the need for a median of exchange. The problem is one of the essential requirements of a means of exchange is it must have intrinsic value, gold, silver, diamonds etc or be redeemable in those items by anyone receiving the means of exchange(money). That keeps the values equal in all locations and times. The problem is in 1913 the federal reserve was created and fiat money began flowing with the government taking the redeemability in legal money, or gold, away in 1964 which is the main cause of all of our financial problems since. Money is an inanimate object and without any base intrinsic value the value is determined by the issuing agent. hope this clears up whether money is needed. Swampy:D:beer;
 
My question to Grizz. If socialism removes motivation, what would you say about the motivations of societies that have no form of economic / government policy? Are they not motivated to live life?
Do humans need governments and money to motivate themselves? Is the motivation that capitalism creates only good, or does it cause harm also?

Wasn't this already covered a copy pages back? Rephrasing the question over and over doesn't make it any different.
 
Here is what the declaration says about governments will that do?

We hold these truths to be self-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable rights, that among these are life, liberty and the pursuit of happiness. That to secure these rights, governments are instituted among men, deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed.

As for money it is merely a means of exchange as the world has evolved to the point it isn't praqcticle to trade chickens for wheat etc, I am sure even you can understand the need for a median of exchange. The problem is one of the essential requirements of a means of exchange is it must have intrinsic value, gold, silver, diamonds etc or be redeemable in those items by anyone receiving the means of exchange(money). That keeps the values equal in all locations and times. The problem is in 1913 the federal reserve was created and fiat money began flowing with the government taking the redeemability in legal money, or gold, away in 1964 which is the main cause of all of our financial problems since. Money is an inanimate object and without any base intrinsic value the value is determined by the issuing agent. hope this clears up whether money is needed. Swampy:D:beer;

Good points. Though, the question was if money is the only motivator in life.....
 
Wasn't this already covered a copy pages back? Rephrasing the question over and over doesn't make it any different.

No, I am still waiting on the answers from others..... This is/was the point of the whole thread.
 
No, I am still waiting on the answers from others..... This is/was the point of the whole thread.
Yes, You're very good at dodging the facts with repeated questions that have been answered many times over...

No, Money is not the only motivator in life.
Many examples have been given. Look for yourself.

Now quit dodging the real point of this long winded debate and answer the man.

You are a dissapointment.








Darren, That is not calling names. It is merely my opinion which has it's basis in fact....



Don't Ban me Bro !!! :D
 
fixed it for ya...since it is what you really mean

No, I just want to here the answer from Ollie..... As he has stated that without capitalism there is no motivation to better ones life. Yes others have stated that motivation comes from other sources, but they weren't the ones making the original statement.
 
No, I just want to here the answer from Ollie..... As he has stated that without capitalism there is no motivation to better ones life. Yes others have stated that motivation comes from other sources, but they weren't the ones making the original statement.

Well I think you know exactly what he means. You are just playing word games now. You can always better your life....spiritually, morally, etc. It is pretty obvious he means monetarily, including property and belongings.

Why should I work my a$$ off to get taxed 75% to see my money go to some pot head smoking or tweaking douche on SSD because he is "bi-polar?"

I see it everyday I work! I really don't think you have any clue....I honestly think you have been sheltered.

I would honestly say 70% of every criminal I arrest (i.e. drug dealers, sex offenders, wife beaters) tell me they get SSD (social security disability) or are applying for it...and/or appealing their last denial. They eventually get it...why do you think we see all the damn legal ads for SSD on TV? Why do they tell me this? Because I ask every one of them why they aren't working or what they do for work. Everyone of them is able bodied, they go for some lame mental illness excuse to get on SSD. Come down into the real world...into the trenches and maybe you will experience some real life....not just book smarts. I have both. ;) A lot of real world experience and education....balanced. ;)

...and of course these losers are all on welfare on top of the SSD.

I'm not trying to insult you...I just really believe you have not experienced what is truly out there. You have not truly experienced the leeches and parasites like I have and so many have. You are a philosopher and an idealist. Come and work with me for a week. I guarantee if you did the job I do day in and day out...your attitude on socialism would change. Your attitude on giving a lazy criminal a handout would change! I know you haven't stated you want to give a lazy criminal a handout....but we are now and by pushing more social programs we will just be rewarding their disgusting lifestyles even more than we do now!
 
Well I think you know exactly what he means. You are just playing word games now. You can always better your life....spiritually, morally, etc. It is pretty obvious he means monetarily, including property and belongings.

The example originally given was school. No money in the story at all.
 
No, I just want to here the answer from Ollie..... As he has stated that without capitalism there is no motivation to better ones life. Yes others have stated that motivation comes from other sources, but they weren't the ones making the original statement.

OH, I'm sorry, thought we covered that.

It is not capitalism that creates motivation. Capitalism merely allows motivation to equal success where as Socialism stifles motivation and criminalizes success.

That answer the question better.
 
OH, I'm sorry, thought we covered that.

It is not capitalism that creates motivation. Capitalism merely allows motivation to equal success where as Socialism stifles motivation and criminalizes success.

That answer the question better.

Good enough I guess... :beer;
 
School was used as an example to prove how ridiculous your theories are. Now what and who will pay for all your wants and fulfill your sense of entitlement? You socialists are all touchy feely until the financial ramifications of your wish list have to be explored. SOMEONE HAS TO PAY! We are sick of paying for people who do not pay their own way!
 
Hmm..... feeling conflicted

finish reading what I wrote before and after the statement you took out of context ....I am saying by supporting socialism you support giving a lazy criminal a handout....ya crackin now? Got it?

...and you don't deny the real world experience huh? No worries, it has been pretty apparent for a long time. Question....were you close to your liberal college professors? You seem like one of their sheep. ;) Baaaaaah ;)
 
Last edited:
This is really just sad. That more than half of America has lost the nerve, the fortitude or simply the ability to provide for themselves and think a government that raids one pocket to fill another is a good idea and voted for it...Sad...What they don't realize is someday all of the pockets to raid will be empty and then they will start raiding the pockets of those that thought it was a good idea to begin with. You wait. Obama's campaign said we will raid $200K and above...they are already back pedaling.
 
Wow Ruffy and I in agreement for the ? second time.
The only difference I have with this statement is that this nation was founded as a republic of the first impression, different than all previous experiments and inspired by god:D. And I also would place the some blame for failure on the citizens who will not put forth the effort to correct the actions of the elected officials, they get the government they deserve. Swampy




Ruffy:
Get a grip, people, the only thing evil about government are the people that run it. That works for all governments, all different types. Every society has failed before us, not due to the type of government, but due to the nature of the beast. It grows, becomes unsustainable, then crashes. Then a new one takes its place.
 
Premium Features



Back
Top