I don't know about AK, but most states have a Consumer Protection Act that provides for multiplied damages and reimbursement of attorneys' fees for (winning) claims based on a vendor's fraud/misrepresentation. Such a claim would likely take you outside the dollar limits for small claims court, but it would also get Poo's attention. You may also be able to cut a deal with an attorney to take a partial contingent fee if you're successful. BTW - I'm an attorney in WA (although not a litigator) and in my experience, most companies won't take threats of litigation (or AG complaints) seriously, until your case is filed and they have been served with the filing papers. Once you have invested in moving forward with the case, they will likely seek to settle. It's usually way cheaper than fighting, and they run the risk of a finding of fraud in court if they litigate to the conclusion, which could be leveraged against them by future plaintiffs. Good luck!