This is a good thread...and a good question.
I can shed a little first hand experience.
For the last 3 years, been riding a 2003 Rev based mod with an 1150 UBR, VE tunnel, aftermarket susp, etc, etc...Sled before that was a polaris chassis with an 809 tripple, full susp, etc, etc...
This year, finally got tired of tweaking, tuning, and wrenching on the 2 strokes and older chassis (I know, Rev isn't that old). On the best powder weekend of the last 10 years (in WA) hit a tree and wasted the front end on the rev. Buddy I was riding with had a bone stock 2007 800 Rev he let me ride. Couldn't believe how much fun I had...didn't turn a wrench all day. Rode more that day than any other day before that. That was it for me. Until.....
Had the opportunity to by a S/C Nytro with all the lightweight goodies already on it, so I went for it. Got a great deal, and I'm loving every minute of riding the new sled. I love the turn key of the 4 stroke. No more oil. No more jetting changes. The bonus is how well this sled handles the boondocking, trees (we ride a LOT of trees in WA), on/off throttle situations. Has the low end grunt of the 1150, but with more top end that I can hold WOT for 10 minutes if I want (not a lot of HiPerf 2 strokes can do that).
I agree with OuraySledder...stock for stock, the new sleds are the equal or better than the lightly modded sleds of just a few years ago. And the chassis are 100% better handling (maybe not if you just want to be a point and shoot hillclimber...hard to beat the stability of the Edge chassis).
Now, I'm trying to sell my Rev, which has close to $30k invested in it. Not a lot of interest, even for less than $10k.
my 2 c
modsledr