So... if the guy who made the mistake lives because he had a pack... is it the same mistake as the guy who dies without one?
I ride KNOWING that at some point in the future I'll likely make a mistake, for me it happened sooner than later, and I got caught, but because I made a good choice before that, I got lucky & made it out.
Obviously it's better to NOT make a mistake... but they do happen. Mine, I went past a hill I wasn't intending to go by, in a whiteout & it came down on me, so had I not had my bag... would I have made a bigger mistake?