Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

  • Don't miss out on all the fun! Register on our forums to post and have added features! Membership levels include a FREE membership tier.

Save Our Elk

P

PowderGirl

Well-known member
I'm not sure if you guys have seen this website or not but thought I'd post it here. The slide has very graphic and disturbing photos and I have definitely learned some things - one is, no one pregnant should be in the forest! Ohh man - my heart is still somewhat pounding after going though this website...

Save Our Elk

I know that there has been a huge decline in our wildlife - I and my family have personally witnessed it in the Elk City/ Red River area in north-central Idaho....


Then:
We used to wake up to several heards of elk in the meadow in front of the house nearly every morning in the 80's and early 90's. Many would come in the evenings too. The dear were always floraging right next to the house to, especially in the evenings - grandma had to take many measures to keep her beautiful garden in tact. At night we'd hear heards of elk walking on the hillside right next to the house as sticks cracked and their hooves clanked against rocks and stomped on the hollow sounding ground. We had two salt licks and often that wasnt enough to accomodate them all. We've had dear, elk and moose in the back pasture all at one time - waiting for their turn at either of the salt licks.

We even had many visits by black bears - once, when I was 3, my grandma and I were in the back yard hanging wet laundry when a black bear came for a visit. We turned around and darted for the front yard - my grandpa just happened to be in the front yard - he heard something and looked up and around the corner of the house came the dog, little me, my grandma and the bear all in single row fashion! My grandpa actually laughs at the situation - the bear turned away though and was gone, he was not threatening us, just curious I think and only came back a few more times before Fish and game trapped him and several others over the years and relocated them.

I also remember as a older child, sneeking up on the dear through the creek ditches while they were licking at the salt licks. I always stayed down wind, making it diffuicult for them to figure out I was there - they would get awefully annoyed with me - they'd stare at me as I would hold really still, like a cat getting ready to pounce on its prey, every time the prey wasnt paying attention, the predator makes quite moves to get closer. Well, I got the crap scared out of me one time - I got too brave, I was within 20 feet, the dear started stomping and snorting at me - that's all i needed, I wasnt about to get malled by the deer.

I also used to take off on little hikes around the house - I'd venture 1/4 to 1/2 mile away in the woods - just me and my dog. It was safe then. No one worried about it.

In the evenings, we'd listen to the coyotes howl and yip - sometimes very close to the house. They were never a threat but of course, I was scared of them as a small child.

There were wolves around then too - they were Timber Wolves and they stayed far away in the remote back country for the most part. You were lucky if you saw a foot print or a feces.


Now:
The meadows are empty most mornings and evenings, the one salt lick is rarely visited and the howl of multiple wolf packs fills the eveing air. The house sits on the edge of a high mountain meadow/valley which stretches for many, many miles - we can hear wolf packs from one extreme end to the other, some in the middle and a few from behind the house - all in a matter of 10 - 20 minutes. It is actually an incredible thing to hear, I must say, (especially to hear two or three going at once, again, all from different directions) but at the same time, it is very unnerving. My grandparents even witnessed a wolf chase an elk THROUGH THEIR FRONT YARD and have seen a pack feasting not far from the house in the meadow.


No, they are not scared of us. There is no way I could let my children play outside without one of us right by their side up there now. I'm not too worried about it here in McCall but they still are not far away. I do worry about human safety - see the videos on the "It Gets Worse" page but we can avoid them by staying in our homes right?

I worry most about our wildlife. Will my children ever get to experiance what I did? Not in their childhood - maybe mid life, if we do something now?


EDIT:
Wow - I've gotten through most of this website, clicking on all the "Click Here" buttons - it sounds like our elk situation is very bad!

And guess how snowmobilers are affected by wolves?

"The wolf caused depradation is so bad that the IF&G has closed off the Clearwater River area to snowmobiles."

http://rliv.com/pic/elk trapped.pdf
 
Last edited:
I will probably catch hell for this but oh well, it is my opinion. Wolves have to eat to. It is called the cycle of life if you ask me. It is pretty disturbing to see them half eaten but honestly it is a cycle.
 
Yes - it is just a cycle but this is ovbiously a way off balance and extremely unhealthy cycle. Do you call near extinction of Canada's caribou just a cycle? I guess it could be called that - the dinasours went extinct. Something goes extinct every day.
 
Yes - it is just a cycle but this is ovbiously a way off balance and extremely unhealthy cycle. Do you call near extinction of Canada's caribou just a cycle? I guess it could be called that - the dinasours went extinct. Something goes extinct every day.

trust me ...the caribou aren't anywhere near extinction up here careful what you read :beer;
 
If the Elk are being managed, so should the Wolf. Problem is who's in charge of the management. Why not just let the hunters take what they want whenever they want?? Would be just as dumb. If not for proper management populations of both would go wildly out of balance. Remember both of these animals were introduced in areas that originally had no population. Not all, but many.
 
Years ago when the powers to be decided to reintroduce wolves into these areas namely Yellowstone a lot of us here in Alaska had to just laugh and shake our heads at the problem that they were creating. Now there is only one solution to the problem just as we have found up here, YOU NEED TO KILL SOME DAMN WOLVES!!!! And yes some of them pictures may seem disturbing however this is life in the wild; it doesn't happen just there that is how these animals kill. I have personally witnessed moose that have been "ham strung" and held at bay at belly deep water for days before they finally attempted to make a run for it, and were pulled down and eaten in the same fashion. This is just all part of life, but if you want to save your hunting privileges your wolf population has to be regulated much more closely.
 
DSC02732Medium.jpg
we don't have the "pack" problems here to take care of our herd, yet...
but we are having a quota & season on the Wolf here this year!
 
Last edited:
Bad wolf!!

I to have seen the vidieo and I am concerned about our game population and our childeren playing in the woods! I grew up in CDA ID hunting, camping, fishing and just flat playing in the woods and my doughter is 4yrs old and I wouldn't let heir out of my sight, I second guess even going for a walk with my family in our woods! I know that sound silly to some of you animal rights people but i can guarantee that if you were threatened by these (monsters) you to would be born again realist!!! These monsters have no natural predators to keep their cycle of life in balance. Just look at the state of Washington and fews years back when they voted out hound hunting for the mountain lion and it took two ro three human encounters with them to reinstated hound hunting again!! Somebody bumped their head drastically when they decided to introduce these animals into our well balanced ecosystem!
LET ME ADD" LETS GET CONTROLE OF THIS RAPIDLY GROWING PROBLEM!!!!"
 
I will probably catch hell for this but oh well, it is my opinion. Wolves have to eat to. It is called the cycle of life if you ask me. It is pretty disturbing to see them half eaten but honestly it is a cycle.

I like your theory. Mine is let man shoot the wolves, let the coyotes & birds eat the dead wolves and let our elk prosper again. *edit* the *edit* *edit* up POS wolves and the east coast peices of doo doo that brought them back.:mad:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
trust me ...the caribou aren't anywhere near extinction up here careful what you read :beer;

Well, this is what I read (well havent gotten throug the entire thing yet):

http://rliv.com/pic/published wolf mgmt.pdf

"Without predator managment these woodland caribou will go extinct in our life time."

I am carefull what I read, and I will read further - I want to be as educated as much as possible on a matter that genuinely concerns me. After all, I dont want to follow suit of a treehugger. So many obviously know little about the areas they want to just down.
 
Last edited:
Well, this is what I read (well havent gotten throug the entire thing yet):

http://rliv.com/pic/published wolf mgmt.pdf

"Without predator managment these woodland caribou will go extinct in our life time."

I am carefull what I read, and I will read further - I want to be as educated as much as possible on a matter that genuinely concerns me.

ask yourself why I am spendin 5 grand on a Moose/Caribou bumper for my truck ....cuz those things are all over the dang highway ....probably see more gettin squished by trucks and pickups than wolves killing them ...

I have a first hand experience and I know what I see not what someone writes after visiting us for 2 weeks a year or less...born and raised up here and grew up on a trapline ......Caribou are doing quite fine.....ya the wolves eat ....as much Moose and Elk as the next predator ...and yes it sucks to come home and find some of your dogs remains still on their collars because wolves ate them .....
 
Uncontrolled elk populations in YNP nearly destroyed the park. Now that the wolves are back, Lamar valley vegatation is returning for the first time in 80 years. Yeah, our parents and granparents remember herds of several hundred or more that would wander out of the park and overrun Gardner, even I remember that, it was as recent as the early 90's, and now they no longer do thanks to the return of the wolf. The herds of 20 to 70 years ago were the UNNATURAL part of the cycle. When we eliminated their only main predator, the wolf, these herds became grossly oversize. While we like to remember the big herds, they were doing more harm to our forests than good. I'm not sure what ID has done but MT will be selling/drawing for wolf permits to further control the population now that it has fully recovered. Push for regulated hunting of wolves in your state, accept lower ungulate population numbers as the norm. Yes there has been a loss of deer and elk, but that is just the numbers returning to normal healthy population.
 
That is what most of us hope for To The Pipe - a natural, healthy balance. I think our problem is opposite of yours except for, we never had over population problems with dear, elk or moose where I am from - abundant yes, maybe that was abnormal? We've always had predators though - bears, cougar and wolves - the native Timber Wolf. I do hope to see elk and the wolf return to a healthy state of coexistance sooner than later. There has been no wolf management in place but now that they are obviously thriving, hopefully that changes soon.

H2SNOW - I'm sorry to hear of the problems your area has with an over-abundance of caribou and glad you have a nice $5K bumper to protect your truck from the damage they can do, especially with as much as trucks costs these days! At least you have plenty to send to Eastern Canada, and especailly Sounthern Ontarior where susposedly the caribou population is seriously threatened. At least that's what the study stated April of 2006. And good point - if I'm not there experiancing it for my self - how do I know it's not biased? May just be another treehugger ploy that I have fallen for. Maybe someone from Ontario can speak up and set me straight?
 
Last edited:
What a total crock website. The one study that they refer to that says Elk in Banff National Park will become extinct because of the introduction of the wolf actually comes to the opposite conclusion. I quote from the summary:

"Thus, conservation strategies based on the trophic importance of large carnivores have increased support in terrestrial ecosystems."

Meaning - in laymans terms - th re-introduction of large carnivorves has a positive effect on the ecosystem. Maybe they should have read the study before they referenced it.

This is just the same "over the top" rethoric you get from the greenies as well. Maybe the "truth" is somewhere down the middle.

Sounds like R-CALF must be behind that website. First we Canadians send down mad cows, and now wolves with super powers!
 
Last edited:
Premium Features



Back
Top