Four Wheel and Off Road Magazine just published their thoughts on a bunch of tires (not all tires, but around 30 of the most popular choices for off-road trucks) and generally speaking, the Goodyear Duratrac and Silent Armor had the most stars. These two matched each other with total stars, but the SA ranked 1 star more on Street and the DT ranked 1 star more in mud.
Then I took their info, assigned scores coorelating to the stars (1-4), and assigned weighted % to each category they had (street, rock, mud, snow, ice, sand) and for my purposes I found the Silent Armor and Duratrac scored in the top two positions again.
Here is how I weighted them based upon importance in these categories:
Street 25%
Rock 0%
Sand 0%
Snow 35%
Mud 15%
Ice 25%