I got a chance to ride
@Pinchecharlie's sled Saturday, and it was amazing! It is very nimble, and wasn't hard to hop on and get a feel for. I would call it tippy at times, and if I had a criticism, it's that I'd like that dialed back a bit. Maybe that's just because most of what I've rode is the opposite and it's something I'd adjust to after enough riding. For sure, the only place I'd take something pretty planted like my Pro or the AXYS sleds I've rode over that maybe-too-tippy setup is in deep snow. In the snow I typically see, not having to make such a positive input to get on edge would make things much easier.
Anyway, it's far and away the lightest feel of any sled I've rode (haven't tried a Matryx or Gen5, FWIW). I'd be doing myself a disservice not to ride back-to-back with a Matryx and G5, but the Catalyst with more power is something I very much want. I'm not going to make any big effort to save up and try to get a '25 - too many other things going on, and I'll leave it to the rich kids to figure out how well Cat engineered it. If there aren't any major teething issues though, I might have more of a decision a year from now...