I've tried C&A's, Simmons, Powder Pro's, and of course the stock 6.9 that comes o nthe mtn sled vs. the 5.9 on the Renegade. Various times over the past 2 seasons in many different conditions. This is what I've found.
Interior/Cariboo of B.C. riding only. This may mean nothing if you ride Wash Concrete or Utah's Sugar.
Stock 6.9 Pilot - I'm very suprised with this ski, works very well for the type of snow we normally get. They float well, carve into a sidehill when you need them, and trailwise, they get a passing grade. They don't do one thing outstanding, they do most things a few notches below.
C&A Pro - My trail ski of choice. Absolutely rips. Best one hands down. Powder.....maybe it's because I'm 225lbs + gear and heavier than my customers that bought C&A skis I don't like them as much in the powder but...I think they tend to submarine just below the surface most of the time. Not a bad ski, if I could swap skis for conditions, these would be the set hanging in the trailer. I prefer a not so aggressive ADX ski as it doesn't try to tear the bars outta your hands when liesurely riding the trail back home. I found the XT and the Outlaw did this. Going up the trail was no problem. Attacking the trail pretty much the whole way. Too aggressive for one hand on the bar looking everywhere but where you should kinda riding. Haven't tried the other models.
Simmons Gen I 6" - Wrong ski for sled. I did my best over a day to get these skis to work. Not for me.
SLP Powder Pro - I'm a bit biased as I have they on my personal sled but nonetheless. I like the Powder Pro's a lot. decent trail skis with minimal darting(for me anyways) Seem to track very well. And well.....in the powder. They float like the Simmons, turn like the C&A, and outperform the stock skis everywhere.(Not saying the stock skis are bad, if I didn't have to replace them I wouldn't actually. That's how much I like them) SLP's for the first part of the year. C&A's for the spring.
I have a set of these on my Mod Cat(don't hang me IDMike
![Big grin :D :D]()
) and love them. Wasn't really suprised that they worked as well as they did on the XP. My mod weighs a little less than an XP with a little more HP. Sleds acted very similar to one another. I had a chance to try it out a few weeks ago, riding each sled back to back. Like I said, I wasn't suprised they worked but I was suprised that with different style chassis all together(1M vs. XP) that they would react so similar. Made me hate the M-Series chassis on the spot.
So, if I got this right, for your style of riding....I'd probably go with the C&A's. They float as well as the stock 6.9 Pilots, but outperform everyone once on the trail or set-up snow.
I've never tried Slydogs but really want to make a fair comparison. My buddy has them on his T-Nytro but no feedback yet. Skis have yet to touch snow. And sled has 3 rides on it.
Anyone wanna donate a pair for a few weeks? haha