Install the app
How to install the app on iOS

Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.

Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

  • Don't miss out on all the fun! Register on our forums to post and have added features! Membership levels include a FREE membership tier.

HELP! 1st time homebuyer, getting jerked around by a realtor

S

sortastock

Member
Hey guys, I'm a first time home buyer and I think I'm getting jerked around by a realtor! I need some help.

There's a bit of a story behind this one. I just took an awesome job in a small town (<4000 people). My employer is letting me stay in a home on the company property for 3 months as part of my compensation package.

We're starting the third month on Monday, so now my wife and I are looking to buy a home in town- (we'd like to rent, but it apprarently it's not really an option here). There are two realty companies in the town. We started with company A, and we were referred to a lender and got preapproved. As it turns out, we weren't happy with company A, so we switched to company B. They showed us a bunch of properties, FINALLY we found one we like.

Here's the first hitch: as we found out, our realtor at company B is married to our loan officer at the lending company. Now I understand that it's illegal for our loan officer to share any of our information with his wife, but I'm also realistic and understand that we're in a small town, and, they're freakin MARRIED.

Back to the house: we found the house we like, decided to put in an offer.
As it turns out, there was already an offer on the house, and she's the agent working on that contract. She told us there have been a few counter offers going back and forth between the two parties, and the seller has the offer sitting on the table, and is contemplating whether or not he should accept. I suspect that the offer is pretty low otherwise he would have signed it long ago.

I'm pretty sure our realtor is friends with the seller- she knows a lot about him, and has him on speed dial, and they talk like good friends. The realtor called the seller, told him to expect another offer. That night we called the realtor, told her what our offer is. It was within 4% of the asking price. She said not good enough, call me back with something better. We called her back and brought it to within 2.5% of asking price, thinking, yahoo, bought a house, little more than we wanted to spend on it, but no big deal. She was to email me the offer letter to sign. She never did. Instead, she's telling us she called the seller, and he wants more. Odd, we thought... I asked her if she could just submit a signed offer to him with a $500 earnest deposit. She said no, we're just going to talk through it. Umm... that's not right, we thought... so I told her I'd call her back and we can talk more about it.

My concern is that she's buddies with the seller, so she has a vested interest in jacking the price on two different levels now... On top of that, I think she knows what we make. We're qualified for about twice what the house is worth, and I think she knows that. And on top of THAT, we're first time home buyers from out of state, perfect opportunity for her to help a buddy out, and pad her commission check a little.

So I've got a couple options to move forward:

Keep playing her "nothing in writing" game
Talk to her boss about what's going on
Just go talk with the seller and see what the hell is going on.
Get another agent to help us out...

Any other ideas?
 
She said not good enough, call me back with something better.
In Washington State that would get the real estate agent in trouble with the real estate commission if reported. The real estate agent is required to present all offers to the seller.

Is this your Buyers agent, or is this the Sellers agent, or just an agent that does not have a contract with either?

Either way, after pulling the crap mentioned above about "not good enough". I would run, not walk, from this lousy agent.

My two cents anyway.

Good luck on your first house! :D

P.S. - If you have more questions, I would be happy to give you my opinions, just send me a PM and I will give you my number.

I am not an active real estate agent, but I do have a license and I have taken a few courses and bought a few pieces of real estate. And unfortunately, from my experiences, there are a lot of not so honest real estate agents.
 
Last edited:
I'm in a very similar situation right now trying to buy some land to build on at a latter date. Without a long story I think I'm going to either A go to the seller directly and ask whats going on or B get a completely independent and unbiased realtor.
 
get a different realtor from a different town

X2

Tell them that you are going to go with an out of town Realtor and I bet you will get some action. They are gona lose 3% if you go outa town. But don't get too excited about goin outa town for a realtor. They will probably jack you around too!
 
Pretty much everything they are doing I believe is illegal in almost every state. There are a couple Realtor's on here that I'm sure will chime in shortly but I would stay in a motel for a month if i had to before I would pay more than you want to for a house. I'm sure the agent is representing the seller and you shouldn't have a contract with them, just get another agent.....and i would find another finance company while your at, if you are double qualified for what you are getting ready to spend you shouldn't have a problem getting anyone to finance you.
 
ditch the Realtor and hire an attorney to represent you in the purchase. yes you will spend a few hundred bucks extra but you will know that YOUR interests are represented, and from the sounds of it that could save you thousands.
 
Is ther a real estate agen you can find maybe in a surrounding town? They work for you. It depends on the state you are in but in Colorado it illegal for the real estate agent to say she will not submit an offer and that you have to go higher. Legally she HAS to submit your offer. Techinically they are not allowed to even offer advice.
 
Hey guys, I'm a first time home buyer and I think I'm getting jerked around by a realtor! I need some help.

There's a bit of a story behind this one. I just took an awesome job in a small town (<4000 people). My employer is letting me stay in a home on the company property for 3 months as part of my compensation package.

We're starting the third month on Monday, so now my wife and I are looking to buy a home in town- (we'd like to rent, but it apprarently it's not really an option here). There are two realty companies in the town. We started with company A, and we were referred to a lender and got preapproved. As it turns out, we weren't happy with company A, so we switched to company B. They showed us a bunch of properties, FINALLY we found one we like.

Here's the first hitch: as we found out, our realtor at company B is married to our loan officer at the lending company. Now I understand that it's illegal for our loan officer to share any of our information with his wife, but I'm also realistic and understand that we're in a small town, and, they're freakin MARRIED.

Back to the house: we found the house we like, decided to put in an offer.
As it turns out, there was already an offer on the house, and she's the agent working on that contract. She told us there have been a few counter offers going back and forth between the two parties, and the seller has the offer sitting on the table, and is contemplating whether or not he should accept. I suspect that the offer is pretty low otherwise he would have signed it long ago.

I'm pretty sure our realtor is friends with the seller- she knows a lot about him, and has him on speed dial, and they talk like good friends. The realtor called the seller, told him to expect another offer. That night we called the realtor, told her what our offer is. It was within 4% of the asking price. She said not good enough, call me back with something better. We called her back and brought it to within 2.5% of asking price, thinking, yahoo, bought a house, little more than we wanted to spend on it, but no big deal. She was to email me the offer letter to sign. She never did. Instead, she's telling us she called the seller, and he wants more. Odd, we thought... I asked her if she could just submit a signed offer to him with a $500 earnest deposit. She said no, we're just going to talk through it. Umm... that's not right, we thought... so I told her I'd call her back and we can talk more about it.

My concern is that she's buddies with the seller, so she has a vested interest in jacking the price on two different levels now... On top of that, I think she knows what we make. We're qualified for about twice what the house is worth, and I think she knows that. And on top of THAT, we're first time home buyers from out of state, perfect opportunity for her to help a buddy out, and pad her commission check a little.

So I've got a couple options to move forward:

Keep playing her "nothing in writing" game
Talk to her boss about what's going on
Just go talk with the seller and see what the hell is going on.
Get another agent to help us out...

Any other ideas?


wow man, that's bad. you need to rid yourself of all this bs. her refusal to present your offer to the seller is against the law if i'm not mistaken. regardless of the offer, i think they're required by law to present.


second, you don't need a realtor. i didn't use one to buy. realtors are never on your side completely, if at all. they're in it for themselves as they're making money off of you. get yourself out of this mess and go it alone. you can get an attorney to do the paperwork, and find an inspector on your own.

realtors offer little if any value. that's why the people in the profession are there b/c they failed at something else.

the main thing to remember is that they are not in it for your best interest. they're in it for theirs. i'd shatcan them and go it alone.
 
Last edited:
well from previous remarks, there are some good guy realtors out there, if it's her listing then as in alberta, she's in a seller's agency contract, representing her seller, and there would have to be a dual agency agreement consent form signed by both seller and buyer (you) if you chose to and then it becomes a very trusting thing imo, and if there is another offer on the table and it's her buyers plus her listing, push away from the table unless you want the house really bad as it is you that determines finally selling price, since your making payments for the next 25- 40 years.
 
Dump this agent as fast as possible. It is illegal for a agent to not present all offers made to the seller. Is this agent a dual agent [for seller and buyer] or just seller agent? In any matter I would RUN from this deal. Sounds to me like she is working for the seller only and will do everything in her power to get as much as she can for seller. Is there is a town close by with a realty company? If so have a talk with one of there agents. MY 02...............
 
You need to clearly define your agency relationship with your realtor. IS this person the same one representing the seller? If she is, you need to either get someone else to represent you or you need to have her clearly disclose her agency relationship with the seller. SHe was supposed to do that ahead of any dealings with you.

All offers have to be presented. THe only thing would be if there are all these competing offers, she may be telling the vendor to hold out for more money. If she's doing this, it's not in your best interest and she's not representing your interests.
 
Well...

Geez, I would have thought we would have seen some sort of reply from sortastock.

You ask for advice, and you sure got it, and then I see that you have not logged back on since to read any of it. Last log on 8/15/09 @ 9:34 PM.

Are you still kicking? If so, what the heck? :confused:
 
Premium Features



Back
Top