Chipping on '15 rails

[Duff]

Anyone else having the finish chip off on their factory rails? All the little yellow spots are chips in the picture, 1 trip on the sled, rode for 5 days, trailered from MN to the big horns on an open 2 place trailer.

Picture of rails

 

[Indy_500]

Mine started chipping on the first ride and I bent them on the second ride. Replaced with anodized Ice Age bombers. The yellow is the zinc primer underneath, the rails were painted NOT powdercoated, that is why they chip so easy.

 

[muskiedoo]

Mine have chipped too. Fortunately for me my rails are black and a black sharpie covers up the chips nicely. I only touch them up when sitting on the stand in my garage for my buddies to admire. Otherwise the snow keeps them covered and then I don't care.

 

[sledneck_03]

mine are chipped as well are rear arms and spring on shocks. rocks being kicked up from scratchers. no big deal. Little touch up paint before selling.

 

[89sandman]

I always wonder who the idiot was who decided painting or power coating rails was a good idea. They always chip and end up looking like crap!!!

 

[Dartos]

I always wonder who the idiot was who decided painting or power coating rails was a good idea. They always chip and end up looking like crap!!!

It would not be much leap of faith to imagine that the paint is used instead of anodize because it makes no difference to the average buyer and the paint process is cheaper.

I think a large swath of SnoWest Forum users are not average buyers.

 

[Wheel House Motorsports]

the paint does shed snow better then anodize but is far more prone to flaking. Also, the cost, even at an industrial level to do rails anodized vs paint is about 5x the cost. soo thats why its done.

Cant powder POO rails being a tempered material the strength is reduced by the process. So between paint and ano, paint is the obvious winner due to $$ side of things. Also for anything besides black anodize is a lot more prone to sun fading if a guy leaves his sled out on an open trailer or beside the house. so the red and orange will look nowhere near as nice after even a few weeks of bright sun reflecting off the snow.

 

[snowpromod]

The paint sucks.....this is after one ride!

 

[sledhead_79]

Its the lack of snow we are riding in this year. Mine did it last year in Oct and Nov. Just think of that nasty crap that those scratchers are bringing up into your skid: pebbles, ice, dirt, branches, etc.

 

[westhawk39]

Isn't there concerns that powder coating rails will weaken them because of the cure temperature? That could be a reason to paint. Although $ is likely what it comes down to


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

 

[purepolaris600]

I thought the Polaris powdercoats there rails and not paints them. also run a set of stock powdercoated rails with no breaks when you powdercoat aluminum you really need to watch the oven temps really close to do them rite without damaging the aluminum

 

[IceAge Performance]

I thought the Polaris powdercoats there rails and not paints them. also run a set of stock powdercoated rails with no breaks when you powdercoat aluminum you really need to watch the oven temps really close to do them rite without damaging the aluminum

OEM PI rails are painted


The temps required to powder rails WILL affect the temper. If your careful the damage is minimal, but aside from very specialized low temp powders, which are basically non existant aside from specialized industrial uses, you WILL reduce the strength by powdering them.

This is why we anodize, paint is cheaper for production, but in low volumes not as much. The anodizing finish creates a nicer looking finished part. It enhances the look of a nice machined part instead of covering it up.

 

[89sandman]

We ride in a lot of marginal snow conditions and I like to have as much snow stuck to my rails as possible to melt and give the hyfax's a little lube

 

[NytroNorm]

Doo doesn't seem to have a problem keeping their coating where its supposed to be.......

 

[die hard poo]

Mine flaked bad on my 14' in a short time. Disgraceful. Had them powdercoated and they are holding up great. I just add an additional cross brace in the middle of the rail to strengthen them. I haven't bent a rail on any pro since 2011. All had been powdercoated too.

 

[Wheel House Motorsports]

Mine flaked bad on my 14' in a short time. Disgraceful. Had them powdercoated and they are holding up great. I just add an additional cross brace in the middle of the rail to strengthen them. I haven't bent a rail on any pro since 2011. All had been powdercoated too.

Negative reinforcement at its best. lol. Reality is most guys wont have issues with it, but it does affect the strength. They don't just turn to butter, but once you see a powdered rail bend compare to a stock unit you will understand.


As for the OP's sled. You can see the rear scissor is also pretty hammered. Gravel/sand/etc getting tossed around in the skid especially if you leave your scratchers down in crappy snow/dirt will make a mess of things quickly. powder, paint or anodized.

 

[05900]

Doo doesn't seem to have a problem keeping their coating where its supposed to be.......

Ski Doo rattle cans better?

 

[NytroNorm]

Ski Doo rattle cans better?

haha they must.

I honestly don't care how they get it on there whether it be coated, painted or anodized, as long as it stays on. I don't care about the ice build up either, I'm just tired of ****ty looking bare aluminium.