Im sorry I just dont believe that one propane tank could weigh more than the impulse tank. They are both made out of aluminum, both made to last, and im talking full, considering propane weighs less than gas I'd say its a close wash, but who am I to judge never seen in person the impulse tank, never weighed mine but will ask the Simmons how much they weigh and will repost. All the other little extras you mentioned are a small wash as well, the exhaust I thought was tiny lol, mounting brackets, really??? Impulse doesnt use mounting brackets?? lol Remember im not knocking impulse at all here, I am sure they are great, I wanted one actually but had it not been for my desire to not run race fuel anymore i went with my current set up with zero regrets, way more power then i'll ever need and reliable power was all I wanted, its crazy fast IMO.