M
mblanken881
Active member
If a plane is on a treadmill, the treadmill is spinning and the plane tries to take off, does it fly?
It depends. Is the plane moving forward at all or is the treadmill simply spinning the planes wheels and the plane is motionless? If the plane is motionless it simply cannot fly unless a very, very, very, very strong wind was blowing directly at the plane and creating lift under the wings. Now, if the plane is moving forward it must have enough speed to create enough upward lift force to equal or outweigh the downward force of the plane to fly.
We had this same discussion while I was in college and I ended up speaking to one of my Aerospace Engineering professors about this. Basically, it is impossible for a plane to fly in this scenario.
Sorry about the long post but this question brings back memories of sitting around with a bunch of Engineers whom each had their own view on this.