Octane is not necessarily the limiting factor, it may be on the stock timing, but you can retard the timing and run higher boost and make more hp on pump than you could without it.
I think what av8tor is getting at: If you run say 11psi with a little race gas on the stock mapping vs running 11psi with the timing retarded on pump. Then the stock mapping with rg will make more power. But the on pump gas with retarder it will make more power then if you did not retard it.
So
stock kit with rg - most power at 11lbs
pg with retard - more power at 11lbs
stock kit with pg - can't run 11lbs so at 8-9lbs it makes less power.
Thats how I see it and maybe it will make sense.
OK, if it can make a PG setup make more power (more boost on same fuel)
then it can make more power on the same mix compared to not running it.
Yes, 11psi with it, and 11psi without it on same fuel... less power with, but that's not the comparison in my eyes.
If I, for example, use 2 gal of 116 (what I run to hit 14 psi, only works if I keep it taped, 3/4 will det) and run 12.5 which is all I can run to keep away det in an all day type of riding, then I'd hope I could run 13.5 or so with the module, and yes, I'd make less power than 13.5 without it, but I'd make more power than the 12.5 I'd think.
When I add more octane, I don't like the bottom end, so I prefer to run a mix, if this lets me run higher boost, or slightly less octane, It sure seems like a win win.