Poo needs to come up with a way to ditch the primary ring gear and starter motor/shaft without getting sued for infringement, or license/buy some tech. That's the beauty of BRP's approach. FWIW, I have had an Earth X last 2.5 seasons now, but I charge routinely with an Optimate LI charger. The first Earth X was dead before one year, which I did not charge routinely, replaced under warranty (it was a great warranty experience, but, still pooped itself).