I also have the Skinz Shorty boards on my '16, and after having B&Ms on my '11 I would go back to B&M in a HEARTBEAT. The snow sticks to the Matte really bad on the Skinz boards. I don't know how Skinz let these boards out with this finish on them, the solution is to strip them and powdercoat them in a gloss finish. I wasn't happy with how the rear mounting of the boards fit up to the rear suspension brackets (and I saw at least 3 more sets that didn't line up worth a damn there either). The plastic cleats are nice for giving a nice color contrast and seem like not a ton of snow builds up on the cleats. The Traction screws are so hard on your boots but with how much I have to kick my matte Skinz to get the snow off I would say there isn't much difference in boot destruction.
Chad