After riding 2 seasons on a set of Exit shocks, Carls valved floats and Stock WE shocks, I can say the Exit shocks are far superior than the other two with the triple rate spring and valving set to the rider weight. They offer much improved control and a very progressive feel through their stroke. They also handle the myriad of conditions you find better than the other two, from small stutter bumps to the big hits they inspire confidence and offer an excellent ride.