They're fine if you have additional venting, beyond stock. The hood gets so piled up with pow that those vents become pretty useless on deep and slow days with or without frogskins. If you're gonna melt, it won't be just the frogskins that cause it on those days. You get way more air from the lower front openings than through the hood, anyways. Frogskins help keep water and debris from coming though the top. My experience with and without them.
If you block the lower front holes, add frogskins, and don't add additional venting, you are turning your motor into a rotisserie. Don't block the belly. Add more vents or a blowhole. Frogskins will be okay.