I go for quite and smooth with decent life, a tire that slaps the pavement with its lugs and cups all over the place is wasted $$$ for me when I have to hit the hwy to get everywhere,,,, Nitto Terra Grapplers. They seem to stick a bit better on slick roads than the BFG AT's I used to run as well. Dont notice any difference in the dirt/muck though but I also dont run an 8000 lbs vehicle through too much crap other than snow in sled season. Get around 65-70 miles out of them.